Philosophical brain teaser

Charles Cowling


Posted by Richard Rawlinson

Some readers might recall Roal Dahl’s Tales of the Unexpected on TV. ‘William and Mary’ was a particularly beastly story about an academic having his brain and one eye transplanted from his body after death, and attached to an artificial heart so they both continue to function.

William can see and think but nothing more. He is a mind incapable of being a person. His widow, Mary, takes the brain home in its protective capsule, but instead of caring for it by giving it learned books to read, she promptly takes revenge by doing all the things that met with William’s disapproval when he could communicate – things like smoking and watching trash TV. He’s helpless and in hell.

As animals, our deaths are defined by the end of the vital processes that sustain our existence as human beings. As minds, our deaths are constituted by the irreversible extinction of the vital processes that sustain our existence as minds. But if persistence is determined by our retaining certain psychological features, then does the loss of those features constitute death?

8
Leave a Reply

avatar
8 Comment threads
0 Thread replies
0 Followers
 
Most reacted comment
Hottest comment thread
3 Comment authors
RichardRu CallenderCharles Cowling Recent comment authors

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

newest oldest most voted
Richard
Guest
Richard

Thanks, Rupert, kind of you. I hope all’s well in the west.

Ru Callender
Guest

Richard, I think your posts are great. Really interesting.

Richard
Guest
Richard

Sleep paralysis must be an awful thing, Charles. I’ve also awoken a couple of times seemingly unable to move for a few seconds, but it hasn’t occured as a regular affliction.

Richard
Guest
Richard

I see, Charles! I almost resent you a change to the final sentence as I also decided it led nowhere but you posted it so quickly it was too late! I guess I was trying to distinguish between a mind and the body that allows it to express its psychological characteristics. It wasn’t intended as a parable about the pros and cons of euthanasia or life beyond death, just a few words of analysis about a tale that had a disturbing impact on a lot of people.

Richard
Guest
Richard

I’m liking you at the moment, Rupert: you’re the only person commenting on my blogs! Too much excitingly combative action going on elsewhere!

Ru Callender
Guest

Remember it? I don’ think it ever left my subconscious. What a perfect metaphor for the end of so many of our lives.