Cash for corpses 2

Charles Cowling

 

You heard it on the news? You read it in your newspaper? The Nuffield Council on Bioethics has published a report calling on the government to find out of people like the idea of getting a free funeral in exchange for donating their organs.

Professor Dame Marilyn Strathern, of the Nuffield Council on Bioethics, says: “The possibility of sparing relatives the financial burden of a funeral might encourage more people to register as donors.”

The report rules out offering people an up-front cash inducement in exchange for agreeing to donate an organ or two sometime down the line.

The whole scheme is so fraught with contradictions you wonder how it ever saw the light of day. The point being that those who agree to donate organs cannot be sure where or how they are going to die; unless a person dies in hospital in pretty good health, their organs are no use.  No use = no funeral payment.

So no potential donor is going to be able to bank on a free funeral.

Which means that donors would be mad not to make provision for their funeral anyway. They may even do the dumb and trusting thing and buy a funeral plan or other financial product.

So when the cheque for three grand arrives, what does it go towards? Furnishings? White goods? A plasma TV?

It’s a turkey, Professor Dame Marilyn. And don’t give us this talk about rewards for altruism. Altruism is by definition its own reward.

An interesting thing about this report is that no one has picked up that it is not the first time the Nuffield Council has flown this kite. It first flew it in April 2010.

 

Guardian report here. Telegraph report here. Daily Mail report here

4
Leave a Reply

avatar
4 Comment threads
0 Thread replies
0 Followers
 
Most reacted comment
Hottest comment thread
3 Comment authors
charlesJonathangloria mundi Recent comment authors

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

newest oldest most voted
Jonathan
Guest
Jonathan

Leaving aside for a moment the obvious holes in this crocheted rag, I’ve been carrying this document with me everywhere I go for the last couple of years: PLEASE DON’T TRANSPLANT MY ORGANS That internal organs can be artificially sustained, and transplanted and go on functioning in someone else’s body, suggests that they have a life force that is independent of that of the host’s body. However; it is less clear that their identity is independent of that of the person in whom they evolved. I do not think personal identity can be separated entirely from physical identity; and so… Read more »

gloria mundi
Guest

Another turkey bites the dust (we hope!) Good shooting, Charles.